Most people often group whisky, bourbon, and scotch together, but that’s a misconception. Each imbues a unique narrative through its ingredients, origin, and aging process. To truly grasp the difference between whisky and bourbon—or how scotch distinguishes itself—this guide dissects these elements so you can choose the one that aligns with your palate. Discover more about these key distinctions at Whiskey Masters.
Understanding the Whisky Family
What is Whisky?
Whisky is the overarching term for all distilled spirits made from fermented grain mash and aged in wooden barrels. It serves as the family name that includes both bourbon and scotch.
Key characteristics of whisky include:
-
Composed of various grains (barley, corn, rye, or wheat)
-
Aged in wooden barrels, typically oak
-
Generally has an alcohol by volume (ABV) of 40% or higher
-
Crafted worldwide in countries like Scotland, Ireland, USA, Japan, and Canada
Types of Whisky
Bourbon: America’s Sweet Spirit
Bourbon is a uniquely American type of whisky governed by specific legal criteria.
What makes bourbon special:
-
Must be produced in the United States
-
Requires a minimum of 51% corn in the grain mash
-
Must be aged in new, charred oak barrels
-
Free of additives
Flavor profile:
-
Sweet vanilla notes
-
Rich caramel undertones
-
Honey-like sweetness
-
Pleasant oak character
The high corn content endows bourbon with its signature sweetness, making it an excellent starting point for whisky enthusiasts.
Scotch: Scotland’s Complex Creation
Scotch whisky is exclusively crafted in Scotland, adhering to traditional methods that give it a distinctive character.
Defining features of Scotch:
-
Produced and matured entirely in Scotland
-
Mainly made from malted barley
-
Aged for a minimum of three years
-
Often matured in used barrels (former bourbon or sherry casks)
Flavor profile:
-
Can be smoky, particularly Islay Scotch
-
Often exhibits peaty characteristics
-
Generally drier than bourbon
-
Complex, layered flavors with earthy notes
Scotch tends to be less sweet than bourbon, offering more nuanced flavors that can include the smokiness from the peat used in the malting process.
Choosing Your Whisky
Finding Your Perfect Match
If you’re new to the world of whisky:
-
Start with bourbon for its approachable sweetness and smooth character
-
Opt for a Highland or Speyside Scotch if you seek to explore Scotch without intense smokiness
-
Sample small pours at bars or attend tastings before investing in full bottles
Quick Comparison Guide
Enjoying Your Whisky
Serving Suggestions
-
Start with whisky neat to appreciate its true character
-
Add a few drops of water to unlock the aromas and flavors
-
Use a tulip-shaped glass to concentrate the aromas
-
Allow the whisky to breathe for a few minutes before sipping
Whether your preference is for the sweet caramel notes of bourbon or the complex, at times smoky character of Scotch, the world of whisky offers something for every palate.
Starting Your Collection
Must-Try Options
For bourbon beginners:
-
Buffalo Trace
-
Maker’s Mark
-
Woodford Reserve
For Scotch beginners:
-
Glenfiddich 12 Year
-
Glenmorangie Original
-
Highland Park 12 Year
Regardless of the style you select, taking the time to understand the differences between whisky types will deepen your appreciation of this remarkable spirit.
