Autumn Evenings Call for the Old Fashioned
The Old Fashioned isn’t trendy. It never was. What it is, instead, is reliable, the kind of drink that sits at the centre of serious cocktail culture because it actually tastes good and doesn’t apologise for its simplicity. As the Auckland nights cool down and you’re thinking about what to pour after dinner, this classic whisky cocktail is exactly what you want in your glass.
The beauty of the Old Fashioned is that it lets the spirit do the talking. There’s no hiding behind citrus juice or layers of liqueur. You pick a whisky you respect, add a touch of sugar, a dash of bitters, a cube of ice, and you’re done. The ritual matters as much as the drink itself. That’s autumn in a glass.
Why This Cocktail Works
The Old Fashioned works because balance exists in restraint. You’re starting with a strong base, whisky carries weight and flavour on its own. A single sugar cube (or teaspoon of simple syrup) rounds out the alcohol’s sharper edges without sweetening the drink into irrelevance. Angostura bitters add spice and depth, those woody, slightly herbal notes that make the whisky taste more like itself, not less.
The orange peel matters too. It’s not garnish theatre. When you express the oils over the drink, you’re adding citrus aroma and a whisper of brightness. The drink becomes complex without becoming complicated. It’s whisky, but better.
What You Need
- 60ml whisky (see recommendations below)
- 1 sugar cube (or 1 teaspoon simple syrup)
- 2–3 dashes Angostura bitters
- One large ice cube or several regular cubes
- Orange peel (for expressing and garnish)
- Maraschino cherry (optional, but traditional)
For the whisky, you’ve got real options. If you want something smooth and approachable, Jameson Irish brings vanilla and honey notes that soften beautifully. If you prefer something with more character, Glenlivet 15YO 40% offers dried fruit and subtle oak without being intimidating. The Glenlivet Caribbean Res takes things further, with tropical fruit undertones that play surprisingly well with bitters and citrus. For something different, Paul John Nirvana from India brings a delicate, floral quality that makes this drink feel refined rather than heavy.
How to Make It
- Add the sugar cube to a rocks glass. Pour in 2–3 dashes of Angostura bitters.
- Add a small splash of water (about 5ml) and gently stir until the sugar dissolves. You’re not trying to pulverise it, just dissolve it enough to coat the glass.
- Fill the glass with ice. One large cube is ideal for the aesthetic and the melt rate, but 3–4 regular cubes work just fine.
- Pour your chosen whisky over the ice.
- Stir for about 10 seconds. You’re chilling the drink and allowing the ice to melt slightly, which dilutes the whisky just enough.
- Cut a piece of orange peel (about 5cm long) from a fresh orange. Hold it skin-side up over the glass, bend it sharply to crack the oils, and watch the oils spray across the surface. Drop the peel in or place it on the rim as you prefer.
- Add a cherry if you like. Stir once more, and you’re done.
Tips and Variations
Use fresh ice. Ice made from filtered or mineral water doesn’t cloud as quickly, and it looks better in the glass. If you’re serious about this, freeze a big batch in advance. The larger the cube, the slower it melts, and the less diluted your drink becomes.
Rye whisky changes the character entirely. If you can find Woodford Reserve Strght Rye, it brings spice and rye grain flavours that make the bitters sing differently. It’s drier, sharper, more assertive. Some prefer it. Try both and decide.
Don’t skip the sugar cube ritual. Yes, you could use simple syrup straight up, but dissolving the sugar in bitters creates texture and ceremony. That matters when you’re sitting down to this drink.
Make It Zero-Proof
Non-drinkers can absolutely have this. Swap the whisky for Seedlip Spice 94 or Lyre’s American Malt, both of which mimic whisky’s warmth and oak character. Follow the same steps: dissolve the sugar in bitters, add ice, top with your chosen non-alcoholic spirit, and express the orange peel. The ritual remains intact. The drink still tastes good.
What to Eat With It
The Old Fashioned isn’t a drink that demands food, but it certainly welcomes it. Think about rich, savoury things: a charcuterie board with aged cheddar and salted crackers, a small plate of smoked salmon on rye, or a generous slice of dark chocolate. Autumn in New Zealand means cooler evenings perfect for standing around a table with good cheese and charcuterie, a drink in hand. The slight sweetness of the sugar and the brightness of the orange peel contrast beautifully against salty or umami-forward foods.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I use a different spirit? Technically, yes. Cognac and rye both make excellent Old Fashioneds. Rum works too, though it shifts the drink toward something closer to a Sazerac. But whisky is the original. Start there.
What if I don’t have Angostura bitters? Angostura is fairly easy to find in New Zealand bottle shops, but if you’re stuck, orange bitters work in a pinch. The drink won’t taste quite the same, but it’ll still be worthwhile.
Should I chill the glass first? Not necessary. The ice does the work. A pre-chilled glass is a nice touch for summer, but in autumn it’s unnecessary ritual.
Why one large ice cube instead of several small ones? Surface area. More surface area means faster melting, which dilutes your drink faster. A large cube melts slowly, so your drink stays stronger longer. It also looks better in the glass, which isn’t nothing.
Liquor Club stocks New Zealand\\\\\\\’s finest wines, spirits, beers, and cocktail ingredients. Browse our full range and enjoy quick delivery. Shop online at https://liquorclub.co.nz or call 09 5900300.
